Arrival is a sequence of handovers
Arrival begins before the reception desk. Directions, vehicle access, luggage, recognition and room readiness can all shape the first impression, depending on the property and how the guest travels.
I would assess how those interactions connect. Does information provided before arrival reach the people receiving the guest? Is responsibility clear when a room is not ready? Does someone explain what happens next?
Consider an illustrative arrival where every individual is courteous, but the guest repeats the same request at the entrance, reception and concierge desk. The issue may be continuity rather than the quality of any single greeting.
An independent review can follow that sequence without assuming which department is responsible for the gap. Observing the guest’s experience is the beginning of the assessment; understanding why it happened may require further discussion.
The practical recommendation should make the handover clearer. Who needs which information, at what moment, and who takes responsibility for the next step? A polished welcome becomes more convincing when the guest does not have to coordinate it.