Gretel Kutan
Luxury Hospitality Projects
EMEA · Globally Flexible
Common Questions

Questions about independent hospitality reviews and senior advisory work: what each involves, how they differ, and what to expect.

What does Luxury Hospitality Projects do?

Luxury Hospitality Projects provides focused independent reviews and senior advisory for luxury hotels, resorts, lifestyle F&B and hospitality-led concepts. The work is split between contained assessment projects, such as guest experience, digital presence, F&B concept and competitive positioning reviews, and broader advisory or interim leadership where a business needs senior support for a defined period or mandate.

What is an independent hotel review or assessment?

An independent review is a short, clearly scoped piece of work that examines a specific part of a hospitality business from an experienced outside perspective. Rather than producing a general audit, each review focuses on a defined area of the business, such as the guest journey, an F&B concept, digital presence or competitive positioning.

When is a short hospitality assessment most useful?

Short assessments are useful when a business wants an experienced external view of a particular area without committing to a larger programme of work. They are particularly relevant after an opening or repositioning, ahead of a new season, during a management or ownership transition, before investment decisions, or when an established business wants to understand where small points of friction may be affecting guest perception or commercial performance.

What types of independent reviews are available?

Current review formats include Guest Experience Review, F&B Concept Review, Digital Presence Review, Competitive Positioning Review, Brand Standards Review and Pre-Opening Readiness Review. The scope is adapted to the asset and the business question rather than applied as a fixed checklist.

How long does an independent hospitality review take?

Most reviews are completed within 7–15 days following the assessment phase, depending on scope. Desktop-led reviews can usually begin immediately. Guest experience, brand standards and other on-property reviews are scheduled around the agreed stay, visit or operating period.

What does the client receive from a review?

Each review concludes with a concise written findings report covering what is working, the most relevant gaps or opportunities, priority recommendations and practical next steps. The work also includes a management debrief so the findings can be discussed in context. The objective is clarity and prioritisation rather than a large volume of presentation material.

How is a Guest Experience Review different from mystery shopping?

A traditional mystery-shop exercise usually measures compliance against a set of operating or brand standards. A Guest Experience Review looks at the journey more broadly: how discovery, booking, arrival, service, F&B, wellness, communication and departure work together and whether the lived experience supports the intended positioning of the hotel. It can be conducted anonymously, but it is not primarily a checklist or compliance exercise.

Does an independent review duplicate a hotel brand audit or quality programme?

It should not. Branded hotels may already have extensive quality assurance, mystery guest and standards processes. An independent review is most useful when it looks across the seams between those systems: the overall guest journey, positioning, commercial opportunity, local-market relevance or consistency between digital promise and physical delivery. Scope should be agreed specifically to avoid duplicating existing internal or brand processes.

Can a hotel be reviewed without an overnight stay?

Some reviews can be completed entirely or primarily from a desktop, including Digital Presence and Competitive Positioning Reviews. A true Guest Experience Review normally requires an on-property experience. F&B, spa, beach club or local-market questions may sometimes be assessed through selected day visits rather than an overnight stay, depending on the brief.

Can reviews be carried out anonymously?

Yes, where anonymity adds value and is practical. Guest Experience Reviews can be conducted without the operating team being informed of the timing in advance. Other assessments may work better with management access, internal context or selected interviews. The approach is agreed at the start.

Do you need access to internal hotel data?

Not always. Many reviews can begin with publicly available, observable and guest-facing information. Where the question concerns commercial performance, positioning decisions or internal processes, selected internal information can make the assessment more useful. Only information relevant to the agreed scope is required.

Who usually commissions this type of work?

Independent reviews can be commissioned by general managers, hotel owners, operators, asset managers, development teams, commercial leaders or F&B leadership. They are particularly useful when the person responsible for the business wants an experienced external perspective without creating a large or long-term consulting mandate.

How much does an independent hotel assessment cost?

Published starting points currently range from €2,000 for a Digital Presence Review to €4,500 for a Pre-Opening Readiness Review. Guest Experience Reviews start from €3,500 plus travel and direct expenses. Final investment depends on the size of the asset, the scope, the number of touchpoints and whether on-property or market immersion is required.

Can a short review lead to a larger advisory engagement?

Yes, but it does not have to. Reviews are designed to stand alone. If a review identifies a larger issue or opportunity that would benefit from ongoing support, a separate advisory scope can be discussed afterwards. The assessment should still be useful even if no further work is commissioned.

Why commission a fixed-fee review instead of a full advisory engagement?

Not every question needs a multi-month mandate. A review examines one defined area of the business, at a fixed fee and on a short timeline, without the commitment of a longer engagement. It is a deliberate alternative to the usual choice between doing nothing and committing to a large programme of work before the actual problem is even clear.

How is an independent review different from an audit by a large hospitality consulting firm?

Larger firms typically staff a review with a team, with the senior partner appearing at the start and the readout. Every review here is scoped, conducted and delivered by the same senior advisor throughout, built around the specific question rather than a standard audit template. The trade-off is scale: this model suits one focused question at a time well; it is not built to staff a global multi-property rollout.

What size or type of hospitality business is a good fit for a review?

The reviews are built for five-star and luxury lifestyle hotels, resorts, beach clubs and destination F&B, the same segment the advisory work serves. They suit single-property owners and operators as well as multi-property groups assessing one asset or one question at a time. They are not built for budget or mid-market hospitality, where the operating logic and the questions that matter are different.

Can a review be commissioned confidentially?

Yes. Reviews are treated with the same confidentiality as advisory engagements. Findings are prepared for the commissioning business only, and the engagement is not referenced publicly or used as a case study without separate agreement.

What is Advisory & Interim Leadership?

Advisory & Interim Leadership is for situations where a business needs senior hospitality experience embedded alongside the team for a defined period or mandate. Typical work includes pre-opening brand and commercial support, interim brand or marketing leadership, business development, repositioning, strategic projects and owner-operator coordination. The scope is tailored to the stage of the asset and the capability already inside the business.

What does operator-side experience mean in this context?

Here, operator-side refers to experience built within an operating hospitality group rather than solely from external consulting. The background behind Luxury Hospitality Projects spans brand, sales and marketing, partnerships, digital transformation, strategic projects and business development within international luxury lifestyle hospitality. It brings an understanding of how recommendations need to work inside real teams, budgets, seasons and operating constraints. It is distinct from hotel general-management or property-level operational P&L experience, and the scope of the practice reflects that distinction.

Is the work mainly pre-opening or for operating hotels?

Both. Pre-opening work focuses on the brand, commercial, digital and guest-facing decisions that need to be resolved before launch. Post-opening work is often more diagnostic: guest journey, F&B relevance, digital presence, positioning, brand consistency, a new season or a business that has evolved faster than the systems around it.

Where does Luxury Hospitality Projects work?

The practice is based in Marbella, Spain, works across EMEA and is globally flexible. The background behind the practice includes projects and operating-company experience across Europe, the Middle East, the Caribbean and the United States.

Why can an outside perspective be useful to an experienced hotel team?

Because familiarity is useful operationally but can make certain details harder to see. The hotel team understands why each process, touchpoint or compromise exists; the guest only experiences the result. A focused outside review can therefore be valuable without assuming that the external advisor knows the hotel better than its management. The value is distance, cross-functional perspective and the ability to look at the whole journey without inheriting the explanations behind it.

What is changing in Marbella and the Costa del Sol luxury hotel market?

Marbella and the wider Costa del Sol have moved materially further into the international luxury and lifestyle hotel market, with stronger global brands, higher investment levels and more ambitious F&B, wellness and residential propositions. That creates opportunity but also raises the benchmark. Properties are increasingly competing not only on rooms and design, but on service consistency, destination F&B, local relevance, programming, digital discovery and whether the overall experience justifies the positioning and rate.

What's the difference between a consultant, an advisor, and a project director?

A consultant typically delivers a defined output, usually a strategy document, a market analysis, or a workshop, against a set scope. An advisor takes a position on what should be done and stays close enough to the decision to be accountable for the recommendation. A project director executes a plan that has already been agreed. The three are often confused, and the wrong one for the situation is one of the most common reasons hospitality engagements deliver less than they promised.

How do you identify a serious luxury hospitality advisor?

Three signals tend to matter. The first is relevant operator-side experience: someone who has worked inside hospitality businesses and understands how decisions translate into real teams, budgets and operating constraints. The second is the calibre of the network and counterparties they have worked with directly. The third is selectivity: senior advisory work depends on attention, not volume. References from people who have worked with the advisor directly remain the best evidence.

Why do successful luxury venues decline after a few years?

Often because the venue stops generating and starts optimising. The first seasons are led by people who had to invent; later years are run against a calendar, refining what already exists rather than renewing it. The menu, the music, the activation calendar, and the signature events become structurally identical year on year, and the repeat guest reads the room in seconds and books elsewhere. The decline is invisible in occupancy and cover counts, which are lagging indicators, long before it is visible. The leading indicators, the depth of repeat custom and the share of guests arriving by recommendation, are the ones that catch it, and they rarely appear in a P&L review.

How do you reposition a luxury hotel that has lost its positioning?

Repositioning starts by resolving what the asset is actually for, not by rewriting the marketing. Most drifted positioning is the result of a series of individually defensible decisions that, in aggregate, left the property unsure of what it is, and guests register that faster than any other segment. The work is to settle the destination first: what the property is, who it is for, and what it refuses to become. Only then does strategy hold, because each decision can be measured against a destination that is no longer moving. Repositioning that begins with a new campaign rather than a settled position tends to drift again within a year.

What is the most common reason luxury hospitality projects disappoint?

Most projects that disappoint do not fail in execution. They fail earlier, in the confusion between having an idea and having a vision. An idea answers what is being built. A vision answers what it becomes over ten or twenty years and what it refuses to become along the way. Strategy compounds only when the destination holds still long enough for decisions to align. When the destination keeps moving, because a strong quarter is read as permission to expand the concept or a new reference point reopens the positioning question, the organisation re-decides what it already decided and never compounds. The work most owners underestimate is the slower conversation that settles the vision before the strategy begins.

What do international brands need to know before entering the Spanish luxury market?

The most common mistake is importing a concept that worked elsewhere without adapting the operation to this market. The design travels well; the programming and the team often do not. A senior operation at this level cannot usually be recruited from the local pool, because that depth has not had time to develop in markets like the Costa del Sol yet, so the right people have to be brought in from established luxury markets and housed, which is slower and harder than most entry plans assume. Pricing has also moved ahead of delivery in parts of the market, and the luxury guest measures against the real thing. Entering well means treating workforce, housing, and market-specific programming as part of the project from the start, not as details to solve before opening.